Topic on User talk:Vish

Jump to navigation Jump to search

Speculation on vague topics

Ganyu simp (talkcontribs)

Hi Vish! As you know, I am creating a page for the Heaven Plan. I saw that the policies for editing discourage speculation when writing articles, but since much of the Plan is vague, I don't think I can avoid speculation when it comes to the history and DIO's personal reasons for creating the Plan. I was wondering if any speculation at all is acceptable on topics with vague areas like this one. Since there will most likely be an influx of new users coming to learn more about Part 6 after the anime finishes, I wanted to give the most concise explanation for the Plan as I could. If you'd rather I avoid speculation, that's totally fine. If I come to a part of my page that isn't explained well in the source material, should I just write nothing? Thanks!

Vish (talkcontribs)

Yeah, since it's speculation you shouldn't include it. Though I discussed about this page with the other mods and editors and we think that the DIO's Diary page already covers the things here. We could probably just make a redirect for Heaven Plan that goes to the diary page.

Ganyu simp (talkcontribs)

Ok, thank you for the clarification. I guess I'll stop working on the page but I'll save it somewhere just in case. What I might do is go the the DIO's Diary page and give the "Corresponding Events" section more context if that's something I can do as an alternative. I think taking the bullet points and making them into a normal paragraph would be more suitable, but what do you think?!